Last verified: 5 November 2026. On 2 November 2026 the Home Office published A Fairer Pathway to Settlement: Government response to the consultation (CP 1707), a 62-page document that sets out how indefinite leave to remain (ILR) will work under “Earned Settlement”. I read the whole document, including the footnotes, transitional arrangements and annexes. This is what it says, page by page, and what it does not settle yet.

This is general information, not legal advice. The detailed Immigration Rules have not been published. Check GOV.UK or speak to a regulated adviser (OISC-registered or a solicitor) about your own case.

The short version

  • Default wait: 10 years (up from 5 for most work routes), if you earn at least £12,571 in 5 of the 7 years before applying.
  • 5 years if you earn at least £50,271 in 3 of the last 5 years, work in an eligible health or education role on a national pay scale, or have a recognised British connection.
  • 3 years if you earn at least £125,141 in 3 of the last 4 years.
  • 20 years if you used specified public funds in the 5 years before applying, or committed a qualifying immigration breach as an adult.
  • Refusal for any adult with a UK criminal record, and for anyone with outstanding Government debt.
  • Not law yet. The Home Secretary told MPs the rule changes will begin to be laid from December 2026 and be implemented over 2027.

What this document is, and what it is not

CP 1707 is the Government’s response to a consultation that ran from 20 November 2025 to 12 February 2026 and received 204,667 responses (PDF p.9, printed p.5). It is a policy framework. It is not a Statement of Changes to the Immigration Rules, and the GOV.UK page says the next step is to “translate the framework into detailed rules and operational arrangements”, with further technical guidance and a full impact assessment before implementation.

In the Commons on 2 November, the Home Secretary said the changes “will begin to be laid from the December Immigration Rules” and “will be implemented over the course of 2027” (reported by EIN and Lewis Silkin).

One related change is already in the Immigration Rules: Statement of Changes HC 1691 (March 2026) raises the settlement English requirement to B2, with the change due to apply to applications from 26 March 2027, according to Lewis Silkin.

Current rules vs announced changes

TopicCurrent rulesNew plan (CP 1707)
Standard qualifying periodUsually 5 years on work routes10 years, with faster and slower paths
Long Residence (10 years of any lawful stay)OpenCloses; temporary routes stop counting
English for settlementB1B2 (C1 gives no reduction)
CriminalityMandatory refusal mainly for sentences of 12 months+Any adult UK criminal record leads to refusal
Government debtDiscretionary refusal above thresholdsMandatory: no outstanding Government debt
Public fundsNo common settlement-wide testUse in the last 5 years means a 20-year path
Where earned settlement stands: policy published 2 Nov 2026, rules laid from December 2026, implemented over 2027
Status: a policy framework, not yet law. Sources: GOV.UK; Home Secretary statement, 2 Nov 2026.

Finding 1: being in the UK is not, by itself, protection

Chapter 8 is blunt: “Being in the UK does not give someone an automatic right to settle under the rules that existed when they first arrived” (PDF p.41, printed p.37). It explains that, unless transitional provisions are made, applications are normally decided under the rules in force on the date of the decision.

The response then says the transitional arrangements apply only to “clearly defined cohorts” and “do not create a wider exemption for everyone already living in the UK” (PDF p.42, printed p.38). There is one important softening compared with the consultation: workers in roles below RQF level 6 will no longer face the proposed 15-year path. They go onto the 10-year path instead.

Finding 2: earnings set the clock

Everyone must show a minimum economic contribution of £12,571 a year (aligned to the basic rate of income tax). Higher earnings shorten the path (PDF p.15–16, printed p.11–12):

PathEarnings threshold“Best years” test
3 years£125,141+ (additional rate)3 of the 4 years before applying
5 years£50,271+ (higher rate)3 of the 5 years before applying
10 years£12,571+5 of the 7 years before applying

The thresholds stay linked to the income tax thresholds, so they will move if those change. The “best years” approach is designed so maternity leave, caring or illness do not automatically push someone onto a longer path. The document’s own example: a worker earns above £12,571 for three years, takes two years of maternity leave, then works two more years. She meets the test (5 of 7 years).

Couples: eligible couples can combine earnings to meet a household threshold of £25,142 (PDF p.17, printed p.13). Exempt from the earnings test: children, people aged 65 and over, and people who cannot meet it because of a physical or mental condition.

Earned settlement pathways: 10 years default, 5 years at £50,271, 3 years at £125,141 (PDF p.15)
Earnings thresholds, highlighted in the official document (PDF p.15, printed p.11).

Finding 3: who keeps a 5-year path

Permanent 5-year routes

  • Health and education roles on national pay scales. “Eligible workers in specified health and education occupations (for instance, doctors, nurses and teachers) will be able to qualify for settlement after five years” (PDF p.16, printed p.12). Annex C lists them, including GPs and specialist doctors, physiotherapists, nurses and midwives, pharmacists, paramedics, primary and secondary teachers, head teachers and social workers (PDF p.58–59, printed p.54–55).
  • British connection: eligible partners, parents and children of British citizens, and UK Ancestry applicants (PDF p.18, printed p.14).

One-off transitional arrangements

  • Care workers who entered, or switched into, the care worker route before the Immigration White Paper was published in May 2025 keep the 5-year period if they meet the salary (£25,000 a year), sponsorship and employment requirements, plus the new minimum requirements (PDF p.42, printed p.38). Those who do not qualify after 5 years can apply for a further 5-year Health and Care visa restricted to genuine sector work (PDF p.43, printed p.39). From 1 February 2027, care workers whose sponsor’s licence is revoked get up to 120 days to secure a job offer and a further 60 days to resolve their status.
  • Health and education workers below RQF 6 on national pay scales (for example nursing auxiliaries and teaching assistants) who came before the May 2025 White Paper keep a 5-year route (PDF p.44, printed p.40).
  • Pre-April 2024 Skilled Worker cohort: can extend visas on current terms until 2035, instead of the previous 2030 sunset (PDF p.44, printed p.40).

Care workers who joined the route after May 2025 go onto the standard 10-year path.

Care workers in the route before May 2025 keep a five-year path if they meet the requirements (PDF p.42)
The care worker transitional arrangement, highlighted in the official document (PDF p.42, printed p.38).

Finding 4: what a high salary cannot offset

  • Criminal record: “Any adult applicant with a criminal record in the UK will be refused settlement” (PDF p.12, printed p.8). The definition includes custodial or suspended sentences, absolute and conditional discharges, conditional cautions, court-imposed fines, community sentences and some civil orders. Overseas convictions count where the conduct would be an offence in the UK.
  • Government debt: no outstanding NHS debt, tax or National Insurance debt, or Home Office litigation debt.
  • Immigration breaches: overstaying, breaching conditions, deception or frustrating immigration control as an adult puts someone on a 20-year path (PDF p.13, printed p.9).
  • Public funds: applicants on the 3, 5 or 10-year paths must not have accessed specified public funds in the 5 years before applying. Otherwise they need 20 years on a qualifying route, or a continuous 5-year period without public funds (PDF p.18–19, printed p.14–15). Which benefits count, and the safeguards, will be set out before implementation.
  • Integration: B2 English and the Life in the UK test, with existing exemptions for children, people aged 65+ and those with a relevant condition (PDF p.21, printed p.17).

Student and Graduate time will stop counting

The Long Residence route closes. Only time on routes intended to lead to settlement will count (PDF p.23–24, printed p.19–20). Routes that will not count include Visit, Student, Graduate and High Potential Individual, Global Business Mobility, Temporary Worker routes, Youth Mobility, Seasonal Worker, Overseas Domestic Worker and the Ukraine schemes. The Government says it will set out its approach to people with leave outside the rules “in due course”. Time on protection or human-rights routes cannot be combined with work or family time.

Families

  • A partner who arrives with the main applicant can settle at the same time; a partner who joins later must complete the same qualifying period (PDF p.29, printed p.25).
  • Children under 18 settle with their parents and are exempt from the income, debt, English and Life in the UK requirements, but not suitability and criminality.
  • Young adults aged 18 to 24 with child-dependant status can settle with their family without the earnings test, but must meet the other adult requirements.
  • At 25 or over, someone must qualify independently or move to their own route (PDF p.30, printed p.26).

Refugees

Refugees admitted through designated Safe and Legal routes can settle after 5 years. People granted protection after claiming asylum in the UK move to Core Protection (20 years), or to Protection Work and Study (10 years) once in sustained work, education or training. Illegal entry ordinarily adds 10 years, except where Article 31 of the Refugee Convention applies (PDF p.36–39, printed p.32–35). Refugees who claimed asylum before 2 March 2026 move to Core Protection, and their time with refugee status counts.

Who stays outside the new framework

Existing commitments continue for Hong Kong BN(O) (5 years), Afghan schemes, legacy Safe and Legal routes and Windrush, as well as HM Armed Forces, bereaved partners, victims of domestic abuse, unaccompanied asylum-seeking children and children in care. The EU Settlement Scheme is not affected. BN(O) and the other groups listed outside the framework still face the stronger criminality and B2 English requirements unless an exemption applies (PDF p.25–27, printed p.21–23).

Illustrations from the document

These are the Home Office’s own worked examples (PDF p.19, printed p.15), not real cases.

  • A social worker earning under £50,271 can still use the 5-year route, because social work is a listed public service occupation.
  • Someone earning £42,000 who is married to a British citizen qualifies for 5 years through the British connection.
  • A part-time worker caring for children who earns under £12,571 can qualify if the couple’s combined income reaches £25,142.

What is still unresolved

  • The exact commencement dates for each change, and the wording of the Immigration Rules.
  • Which public funds will count, and the safeguards for vulnerable groups.
  • Whether any further transitional protection will apply to particular groups.
  • How time already spent on protection routes will count after Protection Work and Study is introduced.
  • The treatment of people with leave outside the rules.
  • The “Highest Talent Group” for the 3-year path is “subject to review pending MAC report” (PDF p.46, printed p.42).

What to check now

  1. Your route: does it count towards settlement under the new list?
  2. Your earnings: your last 5 to 7 years against £12,571, £50,271 and £125,141.
  3. Your start date: for care, health and education workers, whether you entered or switched before the May 2025 White Paper.
  4. Your record: any criminal record, Government debt or use of public funds.

Download the official PDF

The unmodified Government document is attached below. It is Crown copyright and published under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

  • Title: A Fairer Pathway to Settlement: Government Response to the Consultation
  • Publisher: Home Office, presented to Parliament by the Secretary of State for the Home Department
  • Published: 2 November 2026 · CP 1707 · ISBN 978-1-5286-6887-3 · 62 pages

Official sources: GOV.UK publication page · original PDF on GOV.UK. Page references in this article give both the PDF page number and the printed page number (printed = PDF − 4).

My earlier, shorter explainer from the day of the announcement: ILR Is Now 10 Years: The UK’s New Earned Settlement Rules Explained.

References & Sources

  1. GOV.UK: Earned settlement, consultation outcome (last updated 2 November 2026)
  2. Home Office: A Fairer Pathway to Settlement, Government response (CP 1707, PDF)
  3. Home Office: A Fairer Pathway to Settlement, original consultation (November 2025, PDF)
  4. GOV.UK: Earned settlement consultation, detailed findings
  5. EIN: Home Secretary confirms major changes to ILR rules (with statement transcript)
  6. Lewis Silkin: Home Office sets out revised earned settlement framework (3 November 2026)
  7. EIN: Statement of Changes HC 1691, including B2 English for settlement
  8. GOV.UK: Public funds guidance